Editorial Comment Publisher/Editor



The Cheese Makers Who Saved The Cheese Reporter

Dick Groves
Cheese Reporter

September 13, 2019

This week’s issue includes the sad news of the passing of August Albert “Butch” Suemnicht of Reedsburg, WI, a longtime leader in the Wisconsin cheese industry.

In addition to serving as president of both the Wisconsin Cheese Makers Association and the old Wisconsin Cheese Foundation, Suemnicht is believed to have been the last of a group of cheese makers that at one time owned the Cheese Reporter.

What follows is a brief glance back at that period in this publication’s history.

Some 57 years ago, at the beginning of 1962, the Cheese Reporter was owned by Fred Beisser, who had served as editor of the publication since 1943 and purchased the paper in 1957. Beisser served as the paper’s publisher and editor until he passed away on Mar. 12, 1962.

After Beisser passed away, the duties of editing and publishing the Cheese Reporter fell entirely on his widow, Edith. After a couple of months, she offered to sell the paper.

Then, “after careful consideration,” the board of directors of the Wisconsin Cheese Makers Association determined that the continued publication of “The Reporter” was necessary for the good of the cheese industry, and decided to buy it, according to the “Association Notes” column that appeared in the May 25, 1962 issue of the paper and was written by Joseph J. Balcer, the WCMA’s executive director and legal counsel at that time.

But rather than risk the WCMA’s “limited funds” in this venture, without first submitting the question to the entire membership, the WCMA board, together with other interested cheese makers, “decided to ‘pass the hat’ so to speak, and pledged their own funds to raise the necessary purchase price,” Balcer wrote in that column.

One week later, a “Statement of Policy” on the front page of the paper announced that the publishing, editing and managing responsibilities had passed to the new owners: Cheese Reporter Publishing Company, Inc.

“The new owners are cheesemakers,” the Statement of Policy continued.
“The Cheese Reporter is established as a profit making corporation, but its first objective will be to continue to serve, and to expand its services if need be, so that all the individuals and businesses which are the cheese industry can grow and prosper, and provide the people of the whole world the most nutritious and taste-satisfying food we call cheese.”

So, what does this history have to do with the late Butch Suemnicht? Well, Suemnicht is believed to have been the last living former cheese maker-owner of this newspaper.

Records of that era are a bit hard to come by; more precisely, it’s been impossible to dig up exactly who the cheese makers were who purchased the Cheese Reporter back in 1962 and formed the Cheese Reporter Publishing Co. Inc.

For example, a front-page story in the May 25, 1962 issue of the paper started out as follows: “Announcement was made this week by Mrs. Fred Beisser that ‘The Cheese Reporter’ has been purchased by a group of Wisconsin cheesemakers. The new management will be known as ‘The Cheese Reporter Publishing Co.’, a corporation formed especially to purchase the paper.”

The story adds that the paper’s editorial and business offices will be located in Madison, according to WCMA executive secretary Balcer. Prior to Fred Beisser’s death, the paper had been published out of Sheboygan Falls, WI (for more details, please check out last week’s column). But there’s no mention of the cheese makers who were the paper’s new owners.

A couple of months later, in the July 20, 1962 issue of the Cheese Reporter, to be exact, the appointment of Harry Palmiter as managing editor of the paper was announced by the board of directors of the Cheese Reporter Publishing Co. Inc. Again, there’s no mention of who those board members were.

Palmiter purchased the Cheese Reporter Publishing Co. Inc., a couple of years later. The story announcing the sale mentions that the paper had been purchased in 1962 by a group of Wisconsin cheese makers following the death of Fred Beisser, but once again makes no mention of who those cheese makers were.

About the only source of information we’ve been able to come across as far as who the cheese makers are that formerly owned the Cheese Reporter Publishing Co. Inc. is the “Annual Report of Domestic Corporation” filed with Robert C. Zimmerman, secretary of state of Wisconsin, in early 1964.

That document lists Horace P. (H.P.) Mulloy as president of the company, with Lloyd Dickrell as vice president and Elmer Beery as secretary and treasurer. In addition to Mulloy, Dickrell and Beery, the report lists two directors: A. J. Thiel, of Menasha, WI; and August Suemnicht of Reedsburg, WI.

With that (albeit somewhat limited) information, we are reasonably confident in concluding that August A. “Butch” Suemnicht was the last living cheese maker who, for a couple of years in the 1960s, was the owner of this newspaper (or, more precisely, the owner of Cheese Reporter Publishing Co. Inc.).

Perhaps even more important, he was among those cheese makers who, back in the weeks following the death of Fred Beisser, believed that continuing the Cheese Reporter was necessary for the good of the cheese industry. And for that, we are forever grateful, and forever indebted, to Butch Suemnicht and the other cheese makers who, 57 years ago, saved the Cheese Reporter.


Dick Groves

Dick Groves has been publisher/editor of Cheese Reporter since 1989. He has over 35 years experience covering the dairy industry. His weekly editorial is read and referenced throughout the world.
For more information, call 608-316-3791 dgroves@cheesereporter.com

Recent Editorials written by Dick Groves.

90 Years of Cheese Reporter
September 6, 2019

Will Consumers Buy Blended Beverages
August 23, 2019

Time Has Come For National Food Date Labeling Law
August 16, 2019

Trade Wars Just Keep Getting Uglier
August 9, 2019

California Will Skew 2019 Federal Order Statistics
August 2, 2019

We're Just Starting To Learn About Health Benefits of Dairy
July 26, 2019

Is Perfect Day A Threat To Plant-Based Dairy Alernatives?
July 19, 2019

Producing More Far Makes Sense, And Cents, For Farmers
July 12, 2019

Ag, Dairy Trade Will Never Be Free, Fair Or Cheap
July 5, 2019

Some Implications of Wisconsin Dairy Task Force's Final Report
June 28, 2019

Government Involvement in Dairy Ebbs, Flows, And Never Ends
June 21, 2019

Changing Standards of Identity Like Watching A Glacier Move
June 14, 2019

Plant-Based Foods and Other IDDBA Observations
June 7, 2019

Dairy Products Remain A Bargain, But for how much Longer
May 31, 2019

Finally, Some Good News On The US Dairy Trade Front
May 24, 2019

Predicting Prices Is As Easy As Predicting The Weather
May 17, 2019

Not the Best of Times for US Dairy Exporters, But...
May 10, 2019

Another Reminder That Federal Orders Reforms Are Overdue
May 3, 2019

2027 Could Be A Year Of Major Milestones For Cheese Industry
April 26, 2019

No End In Sight For Trade Wars Impacting Dairy
April 19, 2019

Farmers, Processors, Importers Dessearve Better from USDA
April 5, 2019

Is Milk Production About to Disappear in Some States?
March 29, 2019

Why Dairy Product Stocks Have To Be So Large
March 22, 2019

Gottlieb Will Leave Lots of Unfinished Business At FDA
March 15, 2019

Ongoing Trade Wars Are Hurting US Dairy Exports
March 8, 2019

Coke, Pepsi and the Future of 'Milk'
March 1, 2019

Let Them Eat Golana
February 15, 2019

Plant-Based "Dairy' Products: FDA Has To Do Something
February 8, 2019

Plant-Based Foods Get Some Nice Endorsements, But...
February 1, 2019

Enough is Enough; Time To End The Government Shutdown
January 25, 2019

A Fond Farewell to NCI, MIF, IICA and NYA
January 18, 2019

USDA Should Buy Milk With Extended Shelf Life
January 11, 2019

A Busy Year Ahead For FDA, USDA, USTR
January 4, 2019

What do you think about 
Dick Groves' Comments?*

Please tell us if you are a
Dairy product manufacturer 
Dairy marketer /importer/exporter
Milk producer
Supplier to manufacturer



Cheese Reporter welcomes letters to the editor. Comments should be sent to: Dick Groves by Fax at (608) 246-8431; or e-mail your comments to
dgroves @cheesereporter.com.